Costco is a wonderland of giant carts, free samples, and supersized deals that seem too good to pass up. Whether you’re stocking up on paper towels or eyeing that 10-pound lasagna, it’s easy to assume bigger always means better. But not everything under those warehouse lights is worth buying—especially if you’re not careful. Some items spoil before you finish them. Others aren’t even cheaper when you do the math. And a few just don’t live up to the hype, no matter how shiny the packaging looks. The truth is, even the most seasoned Costco members get caught slipping a not-so-great deal into their cart. To help you shop smarter, we’ve rounded up the items you might want to leave behind next time you roll through those oversized aisles.
1. Fresh Produce in Bulk
Those giant containers of strawberries or bulk bags of salad greens might look like a healthy, budget-friendly choice. But fresh produce doesn’t last forever, and the sheer volume you get at Costco can work against you. Unless you’re feeding a large family or hosting an event, you may find yourself tossing moldy fruit or slimy lettuce in the trash. Many shoppers don’t realize how quickly perishable items can turn, especially when stored in less-than-optimal conditions. What looked like a great deal quickly becomes wasted money and spoiled food. If you don’t consume fruits and veggies rapidly, it’s better to buy smaller amounts elsewhere where you can restock more often without the guilt of waste. That way, you’re saving money and keeping things fresher on your plate.
2. Books and Bestsellers
Costco’s book tables are visually appealing, packed with colorful bestsellers and trending titles. But they often come with a hidden catch: a limited selection and no real discount when compared to online options. Retailers like Amazon or even local bookstores frequently offer deeper savings or promotions, and you’ll have a much broader range of genres, formats, and authors to choose from. Costco books also rely heavily on impulse buying. You didn’t walk in for a $24 hardcover novel—but now it’s in your cart, and you’re not even sure you’ll read it. If you’re an avid reader, look into public libraries, e-book platforms, or used book sales to keep your habit both affordable and varied. Costco’s book deals simply don’t hold up for most bookworms.
3. Name-Brand Cereal Multipacks
You might think those giant cereal multipacks are perfect for busy mornings, but they’re often not the smartest buy. For starters, you’re committing to a set combination of flavors, which means someone in the house is likely stuck with a box they don’t like. And if cereal isn’t a staple in your household, the boxes can go stale long before they’re empty. Also, grocery stores frequently run promotions on popular cereals, and they accept coupons, unlike Costco. That means you can often get a better price-per-box outside the warehouse. Plus, if you like variety or tend to switch between brands, buying three of the same cereal can quickly become a waste. Stick to your favorites and stock up when they’re on sale at your local store.
4. Clothing and Shoes
Yes, you can score brand-name jackets, jeans, and shoes at Costco, but it’s not without risks. The lack of fitting rooms means you’re guessing sizes, and clothing returns aren’t always easy if stock disappears. Many of the items sold are made specifically for warehouse clubs, meaning the quality might not match what you’d get from the brand in a traditional retail setting. Some shoppers also note that the styles are limited, repetitive, or outdated. If you’re picky about fit, fabric, or fashion, Costco clothing racks might disappoint you. Plus, without the ability to try before you buy, you could be stuck with something uncomfortable or unflattering. You’re better off shopping where returns are simple and trying things on is part of the process.
5. Large Jars of Condiments
That gallon of ketchup or half-gallon tub of ranch dressing might seem like a steal—but only if you’re feeding a small army. Once opened, many condiments begin to lose flavor and texture quickly. Even if they’re technically still safe to eat, they may not taste as fresh or appealing over time. Not to mention, your refrigerator ends up crowded with oversized bottles that take forever to finish. If you live alone or in a small household, you’ll likely end up tossing a good chunk of that mustard or mayo. Smaller containers from your local grocery store may have a slightly higher price-per-ounce, but they’ll taste better and won’t take up as much space. When it comes to condiments, freshness beats bulk every time.
Read More: Get Them Before They’re Gone – 11 Aldi Foods to Watch in 2025
6. Over-the-Counter Medications
It’s tempting to stock up on that giant bottle of ibuprofen or the 500-count container of allergy pills, especially when the unit price is so low. But bigger isn’t always better when it comes to medication. Many of these drugs expire before you can finish the supply, particularly if you only use them occasionally. Once expired, they can lose their potency—or worse, pose health risks. Another problem is that the bulk format can lead to overuse or forgetting when you last bought it, causing accidental double-dosing. And if your household’s needs change or you switch medications, you’re left with an entire bottle collecting dust. Unless you’re going through these items rapidly or sharing with a large family, it’s smarter to buy a smaller bottle with a longer shelf life and less risk of waste.
7. Toys and Seasonal Decor
Costco often stocks a limited but eye-catching selection of toys and holiday decorations, and while they might look like a good deal at first glance, they’re not always the smartest purchase. The toys tend to be large, bulky, and centered around big-name brands, which means you’re paying for packaging and branding rather than quality or play value. Many parents find these toys lose appeal quickly, or that the oversized sets don’t store well in smaller homes. Seasonal decor suffers from the same problem—it’s big, expensive, and hard to store for the next year. Plus, stores like Target, Walmart, or online retailers often slash prices dramatically after the holidays. Unless you absolutely love a specific item and need it now, you’re better off waiting for clearance sales or browsing stores with more flexible sizing and pricing.
8. Pre-Made Bakery Items
Costco’s bakery section is a crowd favorite for parties, potlucks, and family gatherings. Giant cookies, oversized muffins, and massive sheet cakes are easy to grab and bring to a get-together. But if you’re buying for yourself or a small family, these baked goods can quickly become more burden than blessing. They’re often packed with sugar, preservatives, and unnecessary calories, and the large quantities mean you’ll either overeat or throw some away. Many customers also say the taste and texture are just average—nothing special once you get past the size. Plus, the cost adds up faster than you’d expect when you’re buying in bulk. If you’re looking for quality over quantity, a local bakery will give you fresher options and the ability to buy only what you truly want.
9. Coffee Beans (Unless You’re a Heavy Drinker)
Costco sells coffee in massive bags, often weighing two to three pounds or more. That sounds great if you’re drinking several cups a day or brewing for an office. But if you’re an occasional coffee drinker, your beans can go stale long before you finish the bag. Once coffee is exposed to air, light, and moisture, it begins to lose its flavor and aroma quickly—even if you store it in an airtight container. By the time you get to the last few scoops, the quality often doesn’t match what you were enjoying at the start. Unless you’re going through coffee at a rapid pace, buy smaller quantities from your local grocer or roaster so you can enjoy it at peak freshness. In this case, less really is more.
10. Ready-to-Eat Meals
Costco’s refrigerated meals, from meatloaf to enchiladas, might look like an easy dinner solution, but they often come with drawbacks. While convenient, these meals are typically high in sodium, preservatives, and fat, and many customers say they don’t taste as good as they look. The texture can be off, and reheating doesn’t always bring the meal back to life the way a home-cooked dish would. The portion sizes are also inconsistent—sometimes not enough for a family, other times too much for a single person. Plus, you’ll usually pay a premium for the convenience factor. If you’re trying to eat healthier or on a budget, making simple dishes at home and freezing leftovers can save you money and give you full control over what’s in your food.
Final Thought: Big Isn’t Always Better
Costco can absolutely save you money—but only if you’re mindful about what you put in your cart. Just because something comes in a jumbo pack doesn’t mean it’s a good deal. Spoiled produce, stale cereal, and forgotten meds can quietly drain your wallet and clutter your shelves. That doesn’t mean you have to swear off the store. It means choosing your battles. Focus on the items that truly give you value, last long enough to use, and won’t require a storage unit to manage. Shopping in bulk should be about convenience and savings—not regret. So next time you’re tempted by a 5-gallon tub of mustard or a 96-count muffin tray, pause and ask: will I actually use all of this? If the answer’s no, you already know what to do.
Read More: Timeless Pantry Staples 10+ Foods That Never Expire